The Appellate Division of the Superior Court of New Jersey has held that a municipality cannot simply adopt an ordinance to unilaterally cancel long-term tax exemptions (commonly called “PILOTs”). The Court ruled that the City of Elizabeth’s attempt to retroactively end PILOTs held by Sills Cummis’ clients violated the Contracts Clause of the New Jersey Constitution. It explained that a municipality must follow the parties’ financial agreement, including giving notice of default and an opportunity to cure. In an opinion issued September 29, 2026, the Appellate Division affirmed the trial court’s (Law Division’s) ruling granting partial summary judgment to Sills Cummis’ clients.
Continue Reading Appellate Division: City of Elizabeth Cannot Unilaterally Cancel Long-Term Tax Exemptions by Ordinance